The following is an email that a prospective turntable
buyer received
when he asked a current owner for feedback on the Proscenium Gold
Signature turntable.
Hi Chris,
No problem - glad to help if I can. Let me start sort of backwards with a
comment on my turntable experience in general then I'll answer your question as
best I can. I gotta tell you that I've never really believed that a
turntable could make much difference in sound quality compared to speakers and
cartridge. What happened with me is that I finally upgraded the pre and
the change in sound in my system was so incredibly unbelievably phenomenal that
I realized that there were probably other things in the system that were now
limiting its performance. So I started experimenting and ended up with the
stuff I listed. Each one of those things has its own story and I wrote
reviews on a total of three of them in AA (including the Walker by the way -
please read it if you're interested; you can find it in the AA section devoted
specifically to reviews).
My idea was to replace only
the stuff that was actually limiting the pre's performance but every time I
upgraded something, I got another phenomenal improvement. Not just
significantly better sound, I mean a phenomenal improvement (my original system
obviously wasn't as good as I thought). The kind of thing my teenage
daughter noticed from her bedroom down the hall. Finally, I ended up back
at the TT and I must tell you that I didn't expect it to be limiting anything
and even my dealer, who is a major TT dealer in my area (I'm not going to tell
you who he is because he's turned out to be quite dishonest) didn't think I
needed to bother replacing it. It was a Micro Seiki RX1500 VG with a SAEC
407/WE arm and a Monster Cable Alpha 2 (low output) cartridge. I planned
to replace the cartridge (which was really a pretty good component considering
its cost) but not the TT. The Micro sold for $15000. just before they stopped
distributing in the US and was considered by many to be among the best TTs ever
made by a lot of serious vinyl people.
Ok, my dealer had Basis, Graham, Clear Audio, VPI, SME and several others, in
stock, on the floor, ready to listen too. I'd listened to his system so
much that I had it pretty well calibrated and, like you, I wasn't afraid to
spend whatever I needed to not be limiting the Aesthetix. So after
deciding on the Koetsu PO cartridge, I started listening to TTs, just for
"completeness". Well, I loved the Basis vacuum/Graham 2.2/
Koetsu PO and could tell right off that it sounded better than my Micro and by
an amazing amount and that got me going. Then I listened to the entire SME line
(he has them all) and several Clear Audio including the Master Ref with Graham
2.2, Souther and SME V arms, all with the same KPO cartridge. Each SME
sounded significantly better than the model below it and the 30 was fantastic -
much better than the Basis. But what sounded best was the Clear Audio
Master Ref with the Graham 2.2 arm. It was AMAZING !! It totally
blew my Micro to kingdom come. Now I don't understand why Micro has such a
following still after all these years. They're really neat looking but are
miles past their prime.
So anyway, most important in
all of this is that I realized the TT was now limiting my system in a big way.
Its weird too because if I hadn't known better I would have been totally
satisfied because it all sounded SO much better than my original system and all
I'd planned to do was finish IT off with a good pre. So, I started really
investigating TTs and everybody I talked to said the Walker and the Rockport
were absolute magic. And while I couldn't find anyone who had compared
them directly with each other every single person I talked to said there was
absolutely no comparison between anything they'd ever heard and the Walker Or
with the Rockport.
Now the guy who builds
Rockports doesn't plan to make them anymore (met him - great guy). And
even as nutty as I am, I couldn't spend 75K more than I already had for my
system so I didn't pursue the Rockport and have nothing useful to offer you
about it. The Walker, in the 25K range depending on how you outfit it, was
already about 10K more than I felt I could afford at that point. BUT, if I
felt it was THAT good, I'd find some way to do it (I'd thought similar things
about the SME 30 at some point). So I found a dealer and he arranged for
me to meet Lloyd and Fred at a show in NY where they were demonstrating the TT.
When I heard the TT in NY, it was a revelation. Its hard to describe.
Lloyd played a record I know well (Stravinsky Firebird/Mercury/45RPM version)
and I heard things I had no IDEA existed. And it was being played through
a pretty modest system. There was no way that stuff was getting out of
those speakers if the Walker wasn't generating them. I could hear
instruments I didn't hear before, balances between instruments and the effects
that caused I didn't know were there, ambiance that was just fricking weird
(like a hologram of sound kind of; like being there) and the tone quality of
everything sounded so "right". Not "good", it wasn't a
"man that sounds so good" thing, it was a "wow, I remember that!
That
IS what a double bass or a clarinet or oboe REALLY sounds like !!" kind of
thing. So I bought it. It was MILES beyond anything else I'd ever
heard. Sort of like comparing a really really nice souped up Mustang and a
Top Fuel Dragster. You wouldn't even talk about them in the same context
because they're totally different things. That's how the Walker sounded
compared to the SME 30 or the Clear Audio. Another thing is value. The
Walker is roughly the same cost as the SME 30 (which is a beautifully made
thing) but its about 100 times more "thing" than the SME and even more
beautifully made. At this point, I really think the SME is a rip-off at
that price, even though its made very well and sounds very good. Buying a
Walker at that price is like buying an F17 vs a commuter prop plane for the same
price. The Clear Audio is less expensive but the same thing applies.
The Walker is actually downright cheap when you see what he gives you for that
money.
Regarding your "what's it like" questions, once its up, the
maintenance is trivial. Its not finicky at all. You empty a
"yuck" bottle once a month (plastic thing about the size of a Snapple
bottle that just lifts out of the air supply box) and check the oil in the
compressor about every three months. You tip it forward on the floor, pop
off the filler tube plug and see where the level is. If its low, you add
some Mobil Synthetic oil with a funnel, replace the cap and tip it back up -
very easy. There's nothing else you have to do. Its so well built
that I think it will last much longer than I will. Not a single problem so
far.
Now, as far as putting it together, from what you said, you might want to hire
Lloyd and Fred to come out and do yours for you. There would be several
benefits. One is, Lloyd really is an authentic, no shit genius and by the
time he's done with you that baby will sing and dance. I'm pretty
technical (I'm a physicist) and I put mine together pretty easily and spent a
lot of time tweaking it and I'm going to have Lloyd come out to play with mine
some day just because I'm sure he can get stuff out of it I haven't found yet.
Every single time I adjust something, it gets better (its AMAZING). Also,
he'll probably give you a ton of advice about everything else in your system
plus he's a great guy and you'll just plain enjoy him. He's very unusual
and very very real. You don't meet people like him very often. Fred
is a very nice and very direct guy too.
On
the other hand, I spent several hours setting up mine and in my case I'm glad I
did because I know the TT pretty well now. Its MUCH easier than it looks
and Lloyd would be sure to be by his phone when you get it and would walk you
through any questions or problems you have. BUT, it will scare you to
DEATH at first when you see what he's sent you. There are many many tens
of individual pieces involved. But his instruction manual is pretty
straight forward and complete, and like I said, he's right there. You
might consider doing it yourself and if it gets to be too much, just stop and
then hire him and Fred to come out and finish it off for you. If you
do decide to do it yourself, just to be as relaxed as possible, I'd recommend
you set aside a whole day to do it and take your time with each step. The
main thing is to try not to freak out when you see it all for the first time.
Looking
back on it, it was actually very easy to put together and I think I could do one
now in about two hours. It worked perfectly right off. One more
thing. The base and the platter are so heavy you won't believe it. I mean,
you really just won't believe it. If you're strong you could probably lift them
by yourself but you really should have another person there to help at at least
two stages. Oh, one more thing. Make sure you keep a phone book on
the floor near by when you lift the platter. Do NOT set that platter on
the floor or on a table top or you will never get it up again without damaging
it. If you need to set it down, set it down on the corner of the phone
book so you can gently hold it by the sides when you pick it up again (that's a
Lloyd suggestion and its IMPORTANT man!).
Anyway, I'm going on and on here and I've got to get going so I'll just leave it
at that. Read my review (there's at least one other on there too), give
Lloyd a call (tell him we exchanged emails and I suggested you call him to
"get the story" - I've come to think of this guy as a personal friend
at this point and I'd like you to meet him and see what a neat guy he is) and
maybe get him to invite you out to his place to hear the TT. If you do
that, would you please email me back and tell me about it? I've never been
there and would love to go some time.
Good Luck!
Russ